Minor character Armitage

Having now listened to Sylvester three times in a row straight through, I continue to be struck by the care that Mr. Armitage puts into the voicing of even the most minor characters of Heyer’s novels. This care was one theme of an open fan letter I wrote to him on this site, a long time ago, and it continues to stand out. I’ll have more to say about this work shortly, but I thought it might be fun to poll about which of the minor characters of this work you find the most enjoyable, and for what reasons. I’ve set up polls below for “favorite female minor character” and “favorite male minor character,” and above each poll are youtube embeddings of files of the characters (sorry to do this via video, but wordpress charges money to host mp3s). I’m going to move on later to the major characters (and I realize the line might be somewhat arbitrarily drawn, but hey, I write this blog, so I made the nominations), as well as to a discussion of Armitage’s vocal style.

You might use the comments to justify your vote, or to discuss these voices, or even to protest my selection of nominees. I had no idea there were such vehement fans of these works until I mentioned having listened to them on my car trip — so I’m interested to read your opinions.

***

Nominated for “favorite female minor character as voiced by Richard Armitage” are the following (in order of appearance in the work):

1. Lady Marlow, the second wife of Phoebe’s father. Here, she informs Phoebe that Sylvester is coming to visit with the intention of making her father an offer for her hand:

2. Susan, Phoebe’s younger half-sister. Here, she reacts to Phoebe’s news that Sylvester will be offering for her hand:

3. Alice Scaling, the daughter and serving maid at the Blue Boar, where Phoebe and Tom are stranded after their accident. Here, her prediction about what will happen when the neighborhood discovers that a duke is staying at the establishment:

4. Lady Sefton, a presiding member of the ton. Here, her reaction after reading Phoebe’s roman à clef, The Lost Heir:

And here’s the poll.

***

Nominated for “favorite male minor character as voiced by Richard Armitage” are the following, again in order of appearance.

1. John Keighley, Sylvester’s middle-aged groom. Here, he works on Tom’s broken leg:

2. Horwich, Lady Ingham’s somewhat-too-decorous butler. Here, his reaction to Phoebe’s untimely arrival in Green Street:

3. Nugent Fotherby, Ianthe’s fiancé and then husband. Here, he welcomes Tom and Phoebe aboard the channel ship for Calais:

4. Edmund, Sylvester’s rambunctious nephew. Here, his justification for why Phoebe must come with them, back to England:

And here’s the poll.

***

Happy Birthday month Richard Armitage! In honor of this event, consider donating your time, energy, and thoughts / prayers to an effort that’s meaningful to you. If you need a suggestion, here’s a link to Mr. Armitage’s recommended charities at JustGiving, as well as a link to means of generating a charity contribution on his behalf at RichardArmitageOnline.com, and a link to Act!onAid, a child sponsorship organization for which he recorded a voiceover in December 2010. Donate to Christchurch Earthquake Appeal here.

~ by Servetus on August 10, 2011.

17 Responses to “Minor character Armitage”

  1. What happened to Tom? : D for me it’s a toss up between him and Keighley for the male voices.

    Like

  2. I want to protest: it’s your fault, Servetus, that now I have to order Sylvester and Venetia, because I only own TCM and LOTN. 😀

    Like

  3. hi! I agree on your comments about the wealth of different voices and characterizations that RA is using in the recording of the audiobooks. I enjoyed the stories enormously also because of these accents and styles. I also listened to another novel of Heyer (Cotillon) and, even though the reader and the plot are great, I don’t think she is as good as Richard Armitage in terms of voice consistency and vocal span. Maybe it’s because women don’t have the same tone flexibility for deep vs. high-pitched voices?? anyway RA also uses for his major characters also a sort of baritone voice (esp, for Rule in The Convenient Marriage), which sounds so smooth and caressing to the ears 🙂 Of all novels, I like Sylvester best for the voices, The Convenient Marriage best for the plot.
    The best minor character he created: IMHO Alice Scaling
    BTW thanks for this blog: I am not a blog reader in general but I enjoy the depth and insight of your comments. Some of them are a bit obscure for me since I don’t follow RA so much as you do, but nevertheless I appreciate your deep sincerity and willingness to analyze and sometimes rationalize your feelings. Greetings from Italy!
    Alessandra

    Like

    • thanks for the comment, Alessandra, and welcome.

      It’s been interesting to me how much I continue to love the diversity of voices in Sylvester. I probably still like Venetia more as a whole product, but some of these voices are simply so captivating that I laugh out loud whenever I hear them.

      Like

  4. Nugent Fotherby! The voice tells you worlds about this character-LOL! Same for Lady Marlow…the voice from THE VOICE.

    Like

    • I won’t tell you who I voted for, but I agree that Fotherby is a strong contender. There’s something so unexpected about the quality of that voice, so an-Armitagically frivolous.

      Like

  5. Lady Sefton sounds like a real old lady – I can hardly detect his own natural voice. When you separate the voices out like this, it is more clear to me how distinct all the characters really are. When listening to the whole story, the voice changes are so seamless and natural, I forget that there is just one voice actor there. He really does a great job!

    Like

    • thanks for the comment, Hilarie and welcome. I’ll admit that I voted for Lady Sefton because I wasn’t especially torn on that particular question. But what you describe happens to me, too. I forget that it’s one person doing all of this. I fall into the story completely.

      Like

  6. He does quite a nice job with Mrs. Ord, just the right amount of fluster and worry. I think that his best voices are the characters who are not members of the “ton”.

    Like

    • I thought about putting Mrs. Orde in here, too, Kathleen, but then decided it was just too much to poll on. I ended up leaving her out because she sounded so similar to Tom to me. To some extent I picked these particular choices because of the strong contrast between them. The “ton” voices sound a great deal more similar to each other (unsurprisingly).

      Like

  7. This is hilarious! maybe I should listen to the Heyer aidiobooks at last – I started Sylvester, but was so not interested. It’s simply not my type of book (I have listened to LOTN several times;-)), but these are real gems.

    Like

    • Nietzsche, if I get you to rethink this, that will make my day 🙂

      To be honest, I don’t think that the first disc of any of the audiobooks is the best part if you are not already a Heyer fan. The first disc of Sylvester in particular is very precious. That’s just how the story unfolds. It’s not at all amusing until disc 2.

      Like

  8. What an amazing voice for audio books and voice overs. If you don’t follow RA and you’re just listening to these readings, you would think they are all different persons doing the job.

    Thank you for making the voice distinctions between the characters to emphasize the range and depth of RA voice talent. An incredible voice really!

    Like

  9. […] are the results of the poll about Armitage’s best minor character voice in the Sylvester audiobook. The winners […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

 
%d bloggers like this: