me + a manifesto

I’ve been blocked lately in a way that I haven’t been in years and I think what it comes down to is that most of the time I’m not sleeping or reading I’m either angry or frightened. I have to access emotion in order to write, but these are the wrong emotions for writing for me, and more than anything, when I am experiencing them for hours or days, I simply become exhausted.

I am conscious that this is what the current presidential administration wants — to tire its resistance out so that it can accomplish its goals.

I am going to try not to be tired out, because there is a lot of resistance ahead of me. I’m going to have to get tough and I acknowledge that a thick skin is not good for my writing productivity. I need to find a way to get back to that thin-skinned place and part of me is worried that I’ll lose it, that making sense of this particular version of the world will make me increasingly thin-skinned.

I don’t have an answer to any of that.

But I have studied history and I do know a few things.

We can make laws against things we don’t like, but laws have limited power to change certain aspects of the world.

We can’t roll back the sexual revolution by restricting women’s access to abortion.

We can’t make a transgender person not exist by denying them access to a bathroom.

We’re not going to stop gun violence by giving everyone even more guns and then creating a police state to defend ourselves against the people with the guns. Even in Chicago.

We won’t stand in the way of globalization by building a wall against the people we’re afraid of.

Withdrawing from so-called “free trade” agreements isn’t going to keep manufacturing jobs at home, just like canceling H1B visas isn’t going to magically create U.S. citizens with niche technical skills.

We’re not going to reduce the social services bill by deporting undocumented immigrants. On the contrary.

We’re not going to end political disagreement by making laws against demonstrations.

We won’t keep non-white minorities from becoming the majority population of the U.S. before the end of my lifetime by restricting immigration.

We won’t stop people from speaking Spanish just by taking down the Spanish-language pages of government websites.

Attempts to hamper the spread of information about human-caused climate change aren’t going to stop the atmosphere from warming up.

The wage gap will continue to exist until we address it, regardless of whether we acknowledge it or not.

We can’t control the things we don’t like about the world by buying a bigger army.

And the greater social inequities we perpetuate at the expense of the poor are, the larger the risk we are putting ourselves in when people lose investment in the status quo, when we just can’t take it anymore.

We won’t make ourselves the winners by making everyone else in our society the losers. In the end, we will lose, too, much more than we may realize now.

These are thing I have known for a long time and I have to hang on to them. I don’t have to prove them; they are axioms for action. And when I feel the most frightened, I should console myself with them. The arc of the moral universe IS tending toward justice, even if I can’t see it every day and even if this moment is a bad one, and even if I would like it to happen with peace rather than with cataclysm. I don’t get to decide what and I don’t get to decide how, but I still get to decide that, at least for myself.


~ by Servetus on March 6, 2017.

22 Responses to “me + a manifesto”

  1. Yes!


  2. Couldn’t agree more. Where do I sign?


  3. Exactly.


  4. Good post. I think we all have to figure out how to channel all these emotions towards things that are positive for ourselves and make a difference for others. The very alarming news that seems to drop like clockwork towards the end of each week has certainly taken its toll on me, but I am fighting hard to get past it.


    • I’m really focusing on the make a difference aspect — or trying. There are things I can do that matter whereas other things I might be inclined to do (discussions with people who will never be persuaded) will not make a difference. Life is short.


  5. I keep cycling through despair, determination and denial. The important thing for me is how long I allow myself to stay in each place.


  6. Top post. As a non American it’s worrying enough but my heart goes out to my stateside friends who are living with the domestic side of this debacle too. I’m also grabbing all the positives and the realisation that the network I have ( both real and cyber) is full of good people is one such positive.

    I want to print out this post and put it somewhere prominent.


    • Thanks. What we probably all should do is post the pictures of the people in our networks to remind ourselves we are not alone.


  7. Wonderful post. Around an year ago I read for the first time a poem written more than 80 years before by B. Brecht, “an den schwankenden” – in italian, of course. It bitterly fits our situation, and now yours, I think. But the fact is that now we can read it, because ” the enemy” was defeated. And we’ll do it, again. I’ m tired out, too. But you are right, the arc of moral universe is tending toward justice. So don’t give up, dear Servetus. Sorry for my poor english.


    • yeah — that poem is really appropriate for the moment. And the only answers we can expect are our own!


  8. All I know is I have never signed so many petitions, but you do what you can and you keep on doing what you do Serv, because we all have to—someone has to..or we all lose.


    • yeah, emphatically. This is why I don’t get people who really think we can afford to ignore politics. I can understand not being able to deal with it but I have a fundamental incapacity to understand not thinking it’s important.


  9. I’ve been to two protests so far, and now that I’ve connected online to other resistance groups, I have a No DARPL stand up to go to after work on Friday, and a pro ACÁ protest outside an event that our “I won’t do town halls” senator is trying to slink in and out of.


    • I’m a fairly principle non-protestor, but that is going to change shortly.

      Liked by 1 person

      • And now I’m involved with other school librarians compiling data on schools in our district with/without designated libraries staffed by trained librarians in support of a bill going before state senate. We had over 50 schools without this year, and the number is going up next year. When people’s inability to tell the difference between real and fake news is a civic threat, now is not the time to defund school libraries. Oddly enough, it’s a Republican state senator who introduced the bill. I didn’t expect that.


        • I’m slowly realizing that we have to drop our definitions of the parties — since the election, they no longer make sense.


  10. Yes!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: