Readers’ favorite shots from the Hobbit films
Responses to my question of yesterday: What are your favorite cinematic shots in the Hobbit films? Answers posted in no particular order.
***
jholland would like us not to neglect Luke Evans: “from both angles, looking in at Thorin and looking out at Bardfrom both angles, looking in at Thorin and looking out at Bard.”
***
saraleee: “I liked the moment when Bard first encounters the elf army. The contrast between his shabby coat and the gleaming gold of the armor, and the way they part to let him pass like the opening of the Red Sea — that was cool.”
***
sparkhouse1 says: “The shots from the helicopter showing the company of 13 strung out, with Thorin well in the lead, along the very top of the mountain range.”
***
jholland says: “Thorin walking backlit out of the gold cavern when he finally decides to fight.”
utepirat agrees: “When Thorin finally decides to join the battle and leaves the mountain without wearing his ridiculous golden armor, wow!”
***
utepirat says: “For me the initial scene was Thorin’s arrival in Bag End (AUJ). I watched it in the cinema on 1st January 2013. I sighed and fell instantly in love with Mr. A though I knew his work well before.”
***
and
jholland adds: “the death scene, when the camera angle was low, showing Thorin’s profile. That took my breath somehow.”
***
From @CarolynMasini: “Bilbo sitting over Thorin’s body and he lets out that sob.”
***
cRAmerry: “I like the expression on Thranduil’s face, when listens to Thorin’s cousin insult him in the leadup to the battle. The disbelief about this effrontery, which then dissolves into a sort of disdainful smile.”
***
And similarly, @CarolynMasini: “Thranduil’s smirk after being called pretty.”
***
Kathy Jones says: “I like the shot of Kili and Thorin touching foreheads in Erebor. There has been little interaction between them, and the affectionate gesture is so heartfelt. I see forgiveness, hope and love and despite knowing what is to come, it is an upbeat moment because the dragon sickness has gone.”
suzy: “Kili and Thorin forehead to forehead, when Thorin found himself.”
***
Kathy Jones says: “one more would be Thorin shaking his head “No” after Fili tells them to run. His eyes hold a compelling mixture of grief and determination.”
***
Mermaid: “The last look on his home, which he has given his all to protect. Then he draws breath and stumbles, never to rise again.”
austoz: “There is a shot of Thorin looking over the edge of the ice cliff after the fight with Azog it’s just before he falls to the ground. His eyes are wide, he knows he’s done for and he sees the eagles and sort of takes a last breath before he falls.”
***
suzy: “The scene when he threw away the foolish armor away.”
***
Speaking of armor:
saraleee: “And my absolute favorite was when Thorin presents Bilbo with the mithril vest — the gold lighting seemed almost molten, Bilbo was wearing his usual fuzzy woven clothes and Thorin was hard and clanking in his royal armor. There was something feverish and unwholesome about the scene.”
***
and, last but not least, by almost universal request:
Thanks! I loved seeing all of these. I really can’t decide although the last one is way up on my list 😉
LikeLike
richardtreehouse said this on March 2, 2015 at 3:37 am |
Love this! All of them, so spectacular. Thank you for grabbing all those screen caps!
LikeLike
jholland said this on March 2, 2015 at 3:47 am |
I was reminded, doing this, of how beautiful these films are. meanwhile if you have more favorites, let me know, I will post more.
LikeLike
Servetus said this on March 2, 2015 at 3:51 am |
Thank you so much for your various articles , your great availability, that keep us in suspense Servetus !
(next article english correction: “fascinated Bilbo emerging…”)
LikeLike
elisa72 said this on March 2, 2015 at 4:07 pm |
All of those were gorgeous moments! Thanks, Servetus.
LikeLike
saraleee said this on March 2, 2015 at 4:29 am |
“What keeps me so late” to send my favorites shots ? Only the perilous
reading of “the Crucible” in english version .
So”the nominees are” :
– organic Radagast with birds flying around his hat .
– mischievous Gollum big eyes before answering the riddle behind stone.
– fascinating Bilbon emerging from the canopy surrounded with butterflies.
– inspired Gandalf smoking weed- pipe ( do you know the weed?).
– cute Thorin hammering a sword in a forge and many others of him
LikeLike
elisa72 said this on March 2, 2015 at 2:56 pm |
What a feast for the eyes you provided. Thank you so much for capturing all of those beautiful moments for us.
LikeLike
Kathy Jones said this on March 2, 2015 at 8:15 pm |
Du willst mehr? Bittesehr: DOS, der finale Kampf von Legolas und sein ungläubiges, fast beleidigtes Gesicht, als er das (erste Mal) sein eigenes Blut sieht. Und ebenfalls in DOS, das perplexe Gesicht von Bilbo, als die Fässer alle verschwunden sind und er immer noch in diesem Keller steht.
Ja und dann natürlich die bremsenden Hasen mit ihren fast förmlich qualmenden Pfoten 🙂
LikeLike
cRAmerry said this on March 2, 2015 at 8:27 pm |
As you wrote, this is a beautifully crafted piece of cinematography which makes it so hard to choose.
Thank you so much for making me recollect all these beautiful images from the trilogy.
I just remembered the shot where Thandruil is so very angry with Tauriel. The shot is taken from behind Tauriel, so you don’t see her expression, only her back, but you see Thandruil’s fury, and then he uses his sword against her in one sharp motion. It almost seems as though he would decapitate her – he doesn’t – but her hair moves in such a remarkable way.
It was a very well acted and shot scene, i think.
LikeLike
Mermaid said this on March 2, 2015 at 8:39 pm |
Ach so, ich finde es großartig, dass du diese Momente zusammenstellst. Wenn man bedankt, daß ich noch vor 14 Monaten nur mit vorgehaltener Waffe in einen Kinofilm dieses Genres gegangen wäre, macht mir das jetzt richtig, richtig Freude 😀
LikeLike
cRAmerry said this on March 2, 2015 at 8:53 pm |
I had my own problems in that regard — but now that I’ve given up, everything is fine!
LikeLike
Servetus said this on March 5, 2015 at 5:12 am |
Thank you for all these, some of them are among my favourites – I would be hard pressed to keep it to an even dozen, let alone just one or two! 🙂
LikeLike
Mezz said this on March 3, 2015 at 5:25 am |
Wow, thanks for all the great screencaps!!! They are all beautiful in their own unique way
LikeLike
Herba said this on March 3, 2015 at 9:28 am |
thanks so much for all of these, love them all and it’s so nice to see every single one again 🙂
LikeLike
Hariclea said this on March 3, 2015 at 5:49 pm |
Thanks for the kind words, everyone!
LikeLike
Servetus said this on March 5, 2015 at 5:12 am |
Thank you!!! Loved seeing all these. How could I forget Thorin’s entrance and the first time I laid eyes on RA? Says a lot about an actor when all you do is follow him on screen.
LikeLike
valsgal1999 said this on March 5, 2015 at 6:12 am |